[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":1513},["ShallowReactive",2],{"article-support-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns":3,"related-blogs-support-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns":379},{"id":4,"title":5,"author":6,"body":7,"coverImg":366,"description":367,"extension":368,"head":6,"meta":369,"navigation":370,"path":371,"publishedAt":372,"schemaOrg":6,"seo":373,"sitemap":374,"stem":377,"updatedAt":6,"__hash__":378},"blog\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F10\u002Fsupport-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns.md","Support and Resistance: 5 Myths About Where Price Turns",null,{"type":8,"value":9,"toc":336},"minimark",[10,14,21,24,29,41,50,53,57,60,65,68,71,75,78,86,90,93,96,105,108,111,114,118,121,124,133,136,139,142,145,149,152,155,158,161,168,171,179,183,186,189,198,201,204,207,211,214,292,295,298,314,318,326,329,333],[11,12,13],"p",{},"You drew support at $50.00, set your stop a few cents under it, and watched the stock dip to $49.70, take you out, then close the day back above $51. The level did its job. You just treated it like a wire when it behaves more like a mattress.",[11,15,16,20],{},[17,18,19],"strong",{},"Support and resistance are price areas where buying or selling has stopped a move before, and where resting orders tend to sit waiting for price to come back."," They are among the oldest ideas in chart reading, and they hold up better than most. The trouble is the folklore that grew around them: lines drawn to the cent, levels that get stronger forever, magic round numbers, a retest you can count on.",[11,22,23],{},"Below are five beliefs about where price turns, each set against what researchers and pattern statisticians actually measured, and what to do instead.",[25,26,28],"h2",{"id":27},"what-support-and-resistance-trading-is-built-on","What support and resistance trading is built on",[11,30,31,32,40],{},"Support is the price where demand has been strong enough to stop a decline. Resistance is where selling has been strong enough to stop a rise. That is close to how StockCharts' ",[33,34,39],"a",{"href":35,"target":36,"rel":37},"https:\u002F\u002Fchartschool.stockcharts.com\u002Ftable-of-contents\u002Fchart-analysis\u002Fsupport-and-resistance","_blank",[38],"noopener","ChartSchool defines them",", and it is the version most traders learn first.",[11,42,43,44,49],{},"Why should an old turning point matter today? The most useful answer comes from the order book rather than from crowd psychology. Kenneth Kavajecz and Elizabeth Odders-White showed in ",[33,45,48],{"href":46,"target":36,"rel":47},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1093\u002Frfs\u002Fhhg057",[38],"a 2004 study"," that support and resistance levels coincide with peaks in depth on the limit order book. They also found the relationship runs one way: the technical rules were locating depth that was already in place, not creating it.",[11,51,52],{},"In plain words, the lines traders draw tend to land where buy and sell orders are already stacked. That framing explains most of what follows. Orders are spread across a range of prices, they get filled, and they get cancelled. A level is only as strong as the orders still sitting there.",[25,54,56],{"id":55},"myth-1-support-and-resistance-are-exact-lines","Myth 1: Support and resistance are exact lines",[11,58,59],{},"The belief: if the stock bounced at $50.00 twice, it will turn at $50.00 again, and a single cent below means the level is broken.",[61,62,64],"h3",{"id":63},"what-the-evidence-shows","What the evidence shows",[11,66,67],{},"Even the people who teach the textbook version hedge on this. ChartSchool's own guidance is that sometimes exact levels work best and sometimes zones do, and that the tighter the trading range, the more exact the level can be. They suggest exact levels mainly for ranges that span less than two months and stay tight.",[11,69,70],{},"The order book research points the same way. Orders cluster around a price, not on one tick of it. The study in Myth 2 below even defines a level as a price interval rather than a single price.",[61,72,74],{"id":73},"what-to-do-instead","What to do instead",[11,76,77],{},"Draw a band, not a line. A common way is to mark the zone from the lowest wick to the lowest candle body in the cluster of lows, so the band covers where price actually reversed rather than one number you picked.",[11,79,80,81,85],{},"Then think about where your exit sits. A stop placed a few cents under an obvious line sits where many other stops sit, and a stop that triggers becomes an order to sell at whatever price is available. If you want the detail on that, here is ",[33,82,84],{"href":83},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fwhat-is-a-stop-loss","how stop orders work"," when price gaps through them.",[25,87,89],{"id":88},"myth-2-every-touch-makes-a-level-stronger","Myth 2: Every touch makes a level stronger",[11,91,92],{},"The belief: the third touch is stronger than the second, the fifth stronger than the third. Some traders hold the opposite belief, that each test chips away at the level until it breaks. Both are stated with confidence; the evidence sits in between.",[61,94,64],{"id":95},"what-the-evidence-shows-1",[11,97,98,99,104],{},"Ken Chung and Anthony Bellotti tested this directly in ",[33,100,103],{"href":101,"target":36,"rel":102},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2101.07410",[38],"a 2021 paper",". They used minute-by-minute prices from 2018 for three assets: Lloyds Banking Group shares on the London Stock Exchange, Brent crude oil and the euro to dollar rate. Price entering a level with more previous bounces was more likely to bounce again, and the effect was statistically different from the same price series with its price changes shuffled.",[11,106,107],{},"There was a catch. The memory faded. Bounces measured over a longer look-back window were weaker predictors of the next bounce than recent ones, and how fast that decay happened depended on the asset. For the Lloyds shares the decay was slow and hard to see at all; for oil and the currency it was clearer.",[61,109,74],{"id":110},"what-to-do-instead-1",[11,112,113],{},"Treat the number of touches as a tiebreaker between two levels, not as a promise. Give recent touches more weight than old ones, and keep the limits of the study in mind: one year, minute bars, three assets, one of them a stock. That says something about how levels behave intraday. It says much less about a level drawn on a weekly chart five years ago.",[25,115,117],{"id":116},"myth-3-round-numbers-are-natural-support-and-resistance","Myth 3: Round numbers are natural support and resistance",[11,119,120],{},"The belief: $100, $50 and Dow 30,000 are walls because people think in round numbers, so price stalls there.",[61,122,64],{"id":123},"what-the-evidence-shows-2",[11,125,126,127,132],{},"This one has real research behind it, and the research disagrees with itself. R. Glen Donaldson and Harold Kim studied ",[33,128,131],{"href":129,"target":36,"rel":130},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.cambridge.org\u002Fcore\u002Fjournals\u002Fjournal-of-financial-and-quantitative-analysis\u002Farticle\u002Fprice-barriers-in-the-dow-jones-industrial-average\u002FED089C700C6B674DA8BD1BFB10CA0B85",[38],"the Dow Jones"," and found that the index's rise and fall was restrained at multiples of 100, such as 2,800, 2,900 and 3,000. Once a 100-level broke, the index then moved by more than otherwise expected. So the round number acted as a barrier and then as a springboard.",[11,134,135],{},"Eduardo Ley and Hal Varian looked at 41 years of Dow closes, from January 1952 to June 1993, in a 1994 paper. At first the century marks looked more like a launch pad than a barrier, but the pattern did not hold up across subsamples. Their conclusion was that there is \"little if any predictive power in the closing values\" of the index.",[11,137,138],{},"Both studies looked at an index, not at a single stock, and both are decades old.",[61,140,74],{"id":141},"what-to-do-instead-2",[11,143,144],{},"Treat a round number as a place where orders might cluster, which fits the order book research above. Give it weight only when price has actually reacted there on your chart. A round number that price has sliced through three times without pausing is just a number.",[25,146,148],{"id":147},"myth-4-broken-resistance-always-comes-back-as-support","Myth 4: Broken resistance always comes back as support",[11,150,151],{},"The belief, often called role reversal: once price breaks above resistance, it will come back to test that level from above, and the old ceiling will act as a floor. Many traders plan their entry around that retest.",[61,153,64],{"id":154},"what-the-evidence-shows-3",[11,156,157],{},"Thomas Bulkowski, who has catalogued chart patterns for decades, measured this return trip and calls it a throwback when it happens within 30 days of an upward breakout. Since 2000, 58% of 10,305 chart patterns with upward breakouts in his data had a throwback. Price climbed for 6 days on average before turning back, and the whole round trip took about 10 days.",[11,159,160],{},"Read the other side of that number: about 4 in 10 breakouts never came back to offer the retest. And of those that did return to the breakout price, 35% kept falling below the chart pattern. Worked through, that is roughly one in five of all the upward breakouts in his sample where the old resistance did not hold as support. Bulkowski names overhead resistance as the chief cause of a throwback in the first place.",[162,163],"img",{"src":164,"alt":165,"width":166,"height":167},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fsupport-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns\u002Fsupport-zone-throwback.jpg","Diagram of price breaking up through a resistance zone, then one path returning to hold the zone and another path falling back through it",1067,600,[61,169,74],{"id":170},"what-to-do-instead-3",[11,172,173,174,178],{},"Plan for three outcomes, not one: no retest, a retest that holds, and a retest that fails. If your whole plan depends on the retest, you will either miss the move or buy the failed one. The same logic applies to the neckline of a pattern; this walkthrough of ",[33,175,177],{"href":176},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fdouble-bottom-pattern-from-two-lows-to-a-confirmed-break","double bottom breakouts"," shows what a confirmed break and a failed one look like side by side.",[25,180,182],{"id":181},"myth-5-a-big-volume-breakout-is-the-one-that-sticks","Myth 5: A big-volume breakout is the one that sticks",[11,184,185],{},"The belief: a break through support or resistance on light volume is suspect, and one on heavy volume is the real thing.",[61,187,64],{"id":188},"what-the-evidence-shows-4",[11,190,191,192,197],{},"Bulkowski tested this too, in a ",[33,193,196],{"href":194,"target":36,"rel":195},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.thepatternsite.com\u002FVolumeStudy.html",[38],"volume study"," of over 8,000 chart patterns from July 1991 to May 2011. He kept only rectangles and double and triple tops and bottoms, patterns where the breakout level is clearly defined, and compared breakout-day volume with the previous 31 calendar days.",[11,199,200],{},"The results ran against the textbook. Measured by how often price failed to move more than 10% after the breakout, upward breakouts on above-average volume failed 14% of the time against 5% on below-average volume. For downward breakouts it was 28% against 11%. Throwbacks followed 57% of high-volume upward breakouts against 18% of low-volume ones, and pullbacks after downward breaks showed the same split, 47% against 17%.",[61,202,74],{"id":203},"what-to-do-instead-4",[11,205,206],{},"Read heavy volume at a break as a sign that a lot of orders traded through the level, not as a verdict on direction. In this sample a loud breakout was more likely to come back and test the level, so the third outcome from Myth 4 deserves more weight after a high-volume break, not less.",[25,208,210],{"id":209},"how-to-read-levels-with-less-faith","How to read levels with less faith",[11,212,213],{},"Here is the whole list in one place, with the sample behind each finding.",[215,216,217,233],"table",{},[218,219,220],"thead",{},[221,222,223,227,230],"tr",{},[224,225,226],"th",{},"Myth",[224,228,229],{},"What was measured",[224,231,232],{},"Sample",[234,235,236,248,259,270,281],"tbody",{},[221,237,238,242,245],{},[239,240,241],"td",{},"Levels are exact lines",[239,243,244],{},"Levels coincide with peaks in resting order depth",[239,246,247],{},"Kavajecz and Odders-White, limit order book data",[221,249,250,253,256],{},[239,251,252],{},"Every touch adds strength",[239,254,255],{},"More prior bounces, more bounces next, but the effect fades",[239,257,258],{},"Chung and Bellotti, minute data, 2018, three assets",[221,260,261,264,267],{},[239,262,263],{},"Round numbers are walls",[239,265,266],{},"Dow restrained at 100-levels in one study, no predictive power in another",[239,268,269],{},"Dow Jones closes, 1952 to 1993",[221,271,272,275,278],{},[239,273,274],{},"Broken resistance becomes support",[239,276,277],{},"58% returned to the breakout; 35% of those kept falling",[239,279,280],{},"Bulkowski, 10,305 patterns since 2000",[221,282,283,286,289],{},[239,284,285],{},"High volume confirms a break",[239,287,288],{},"High-volume breaks failed and threw back more often",[239,290,291],{},"Bulkowski, 8,000+ patterns, 1991 to 2011",[11,293,294],{},"Every figure here is a past frequency from a named sample. None of it tells you what the next stock you look at will do.",[11,296,297],{},"In practice, that leaves a short working method:",[299,300,301,305,308,311],"ul",{},[302,303,304],"li",{},"Mark zones from clusters of reversals, and weight recent reversals over old ones.",[302,306,307],{},"Count a round number only where price has visibly reacted to it.",[302,309,310],{},"Before a breakout, write down what you will do if there is no retest, a retest that holds, and a retest that fails.",[302,312,313],{},"Treat breakout volume as information about activity, not as confirmation.",[61,315,317],{"id":316},"where-an-ai-read-fits","Where an AI read fits",[11,319,320,321,325],{},"If you want a second read on a chart you have already marked up, Primo Trade can take a photo or screenshot of it. Its Analyze Chart feature gives the AI's read of trend, volatility, volume and sentiment, the chart pattern it sees and what that pattern usually signals, along with a Primo Score and Key Insights. It does not replace your own levels; it gives you another view to set beside them. If you want to look up a pattern by its shape, the ",[33,322,324],{"href":323},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fchart-patterns-cheat-sheet","chart patterns cheat sheet"," lays out the common ones.",[11,327,328],{},"Primo Trade gives AI-generated analysis for information and education. It is not financial advice. Markets carry risk; do your own research before you trade.",[25,330,332],{"id":331},"the-short-version","The short version",[11,334,335],{},"Support and resistance are real enough to study and loose enough to mislead. They mark where orders tend to rest, so they behave like zones, not lines. Touches matter, but recent ones matter more and the effect fades. Round numbers have mixed evidence and deserve weight only when price reacts to them. The retest after a breakout happened in a little over half of one large sample, and a third of those retests failed. Heavy volume at a break made a return trip more likely, not less. Draw the zone, plan for each outcome, and hold every level a little more loosely than the chart makes it look.",{"title":337,"searchDepth":338,"depth":338,"links":339},"",2,[340,341,346,350,354,358,362,365],{"id":27,"depth":338,"text":28},{"id":55,"depth":338,"text":56,"children":342},[343,345],{"id":63,"depth":344,"text":64},3,{"id":73,"depth":344,"text":74},{"id":88,"depth":338,"text":89,"children":347},[348,349],{"id":95,"depth":344,"text":64},{"id":110,"depth":344,"text":74},{"id":116,"depth":338,"text":117,"children":351},[352,353],{"id":123,"depth":344,"text":64},{"id":141,"depth":344,"text":74},{"id":147,"depth":338,"text":148,"children":355},[356,357],{"id":154,"depth":344,"text":64},{"id":170,"depth":344,"text":74},{"id":181,"depth":338,"text":182,"children":359},[360,361],{"id":188,"depth":344,"text":64},{"id":203,"depth":344,"text":74},{"id":209,"depth":338,"text":210,"children":363},[364],{"id":316,"depth":344,"text":317},{"id":331,"depth":338,"text":332},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fsupport-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns.jpg","Support and resistance are zones, not lines. Five myths about where price turns, checked against studies of order books, round numbers and breakouts.","md",{},true,"\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F10\u002Fsupport-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns","2026-10-29",{"title":5,"description":367},{"loc":371,"images":375},[376],{"loc":164},"blog\u002F2026\u002F10\u002Fsupport-and-resistance-5-myths-about-where-price-turns","L9ejdzeex_FVlchJz14y4lOdVPlmHJbr3ZgWTVPU9DQ",[380,771,1150],{"id":381,"title":382,"author":6,"body":383,"coverImg":760,"description":761,"extension":368,"head":6,"meta":762,"navigation":370,"path":763,"publishedAt":764,"schemaOrg":6,"seo":765,"sitemap":766,"stem":769,"updatedAt":6,"__hash__":770},"blog\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fpe-ratio-five-myths-about-cheap-and-expensive-stocks.md","PE Ratio: Five Myths About Cheap and Expensive Stocks",{"type":8,"value":384,"toc":739},[385,388,391,394,398,407,410,421,425,434,443,505,508,512,515,520,524,533,536,540,543,546,550,556,560,563,567,570,573,579,583,586,589,593,596,599,602,651,654,658,661,670,675,679,682,685,693,698,702,705,722,724,727,730,733,736],[11,386,387],{},"You sort a screener by the lowest PE ratio, and a well-known chip maker sits near the top at about 7. It looks like the market forgot to price it. That was Micron in September 2022, and its next fiscal year ended in a $5.83 billion loss.",[11,389,390],{},"The PE ratio, short for price to earnings, is the share price divided by a year of earnings per share. It tells you how many dollars investors pay for one dollar of a company's annual earnings. There is no single good PE ratio: the number means something only next to the same company's history, its sector and the direction its earnings are heading.",[11,392,393],{},"That last sentence is where most PE mistakes start. Below are five beliefs about the ratio that sound sensible, and the numbers that break each one.",[25,395,397],{"id":396},"what-the-pe-ratio-actually-measures","What the PE Ratio Actually Measures",[11,399,400,401,406],{},"The SEC's ",[33,402,405],{"href":403,"target":36,"rel":404},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.investor.gov\u002Fintroduction-investing\u002Finvesting-basics\u002Fglossary\u002Fprice-earnings-pe-ratio",[38],"investor education site",", Investor.gov, defines it plainly: divide the current share price by the current earnings per share, where earnings per share are the past 12 months of earnings divided by the shares outstanding. It is a way of gauging whether a price is high or low compared with the past or with other companies.",[11,408,409],{},"The arithmetic is short. A stock at $50 with $2.50 of earnings per share over the last year has a PE ratio of 20. Investors are paying 20 times one year of earnings for a share.",[11,411,412,415,416,420],{},[17,413,414],{},"The ratio has two moving parts, and most myths come from watching only the price."," Earnings change every quarter, and the ratio moves when they do, even if the price sits still. Earnings per share is also less tidy than it looks; one quarter can produce three different figures, as our post on ",[33,417,419],{"href":418},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fearnings-per-share-why-one-quarter-has-three-numbers","earnings per share"," walks through.",[25,422,424],{"id":423},"myth-1-a-pe-ratio-under-15-means-a-stock-is-cheap","Myth 1: A PE Ratio Under 15 Means a Stock Is Cheap",[11,426,427,428,433],{},"The number 15 gets passed around as a dividing line. ",[33,429,432],{"href":430,"target":36,"rel":431},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.schwab.com\u002Flearn\u002Fstory\u002Fstock-analysis-using-pe-ratio",[38],"Charles Schwab's guide"," notes that readings below 15 are commonly called low and those above 30 high, then adds the part people skip: there is no universal standard, and the readings only mean something in context.",[11,435,436,437,442],{},"Context starts with the sector. Here are forward PE ratios for parts of the S&P 500 as FactSet's weekly ",[33,438,441],{"href":439,"target":36,"rel":440},"https:\u002F\u002Fadvantage.factset.com\u002Fhubfs\u002FWebsite\u002FResources%20Section\u002FResearch%20Desk\u002FEarnings%20Insight\u002FEarningsInsight_103026.pdf",[38],"Earnings Insight"," reported them on October 30, 2026:",[215,444,445,455],{},[218,446,447],{},[221,448,449,452],{},[224,450,451],{},"Group",[224,453,454],{},"Forward 12-month PE",[234,456,457,465,473,481,489,497],{},[221,458,459,462],{},[239,460,461],{},"Consumer Discretionary",[239,463,464],{},"23.8",[221,466,467,470],{},[239,468,469],{},"Consumer Staples",[239,471,472],{},"22.9",[221,474,475,478],{},[239,476,477],{},"Industrials",[239,479,480],{},"22.8",[221,482,483,486],{},[239,484,485],{},"S&P 500",[239,487,488],{},"18.7",[221,490,491,494],{},[239,492,493],{},"Financials",[239,495,496],{},"14.9",[221,498,499,502],{},[239,500,501],{},"Energy",[239,503,504],{},"13.2",[11,506,507],{},"An energy company at 14 sits above its sector's figure. A consumer staples company at 14 sits far below its own. Same number, opposite readings.",[61,509,511],{"id":510},"what-to-compare-it-with-instead","What to compare it with instead",[11,513,514],{},"Compare a stock's PE with its own history and with direct peers, not with a round number. Schwab makes the same point inside a single sector: semiconductor companies often carry a much higher average PE than computer hardware makers, although both sit in technology.",[11,516,517],{},[17,518,519],{},"A PE ratio is a relative number, and 15 is a habit, not a benchmark.",[25,521,523],{"id":522},"myth-2-a-low-pe-ratio-is-always-a-bargain","Myth 2: A Low PE Ratio Is Always a Bargain",[11,525,526,527,532],{},"Back to Micron. Its trailing PE was 12.6 at the end of the quarter on December 2, 2021, and 11.1 at the end of the quarter on March 3, 2022, per StockAnalysis figures ",[33,528,531],{"href":529,"target":36,"rel":530},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.stocktitan.net\u002Farticles\u002Fmicron-q4-fy2026-earnings-memory-cycle",[38],"compiled by StockTitan",". In between, on January 14, 2022, the stock set a closing high of $97.36.",[11,534,535],{},"By September 26, 2022 it had closed at $48.88, down 49.8%. The trailing PE at the quarter end of September 1, 2022 was 7.3. The stock looked cheaper every month it fell.",[61,537,539],{"id":538},"why-the-ratio-looked-cheapest-at-the-top","Why the ratio looked cheapest at the top",[11,541,542],{},"Memory chip earnings rise and fall with memory prices. In fiscal 2022 Micron reported diluted earnings of $7.75 a share, the peak year of that cycle. The PE was low because the earnings underneath it were at a high.",[11,544,545],{},"Then the earnings moved. In fiscal 2023 Micron's revenue fell 49.5%, its gross margin for the year was negative 9.1%, and it lost $5.83 billion. The share price had started falling while the most recently reported gross margin was still above 46%; the collapse showed up only in the reports that followed.",[162,547],{"src":548,"alt":549,"width":166,"height":167},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fpe-ratio-five-myths-about-cheap-and-expensive-stocks\u002Flow-pe-at-peak-earnings.jpg","Diagram of a share price line falling while earnings bars rise to a peak and then drop below zero, with the low PE marked at the earnings peak",[11,551,552,555],{},[17,553,554],{},"For a cyclical company, a low PE can mean earnings are near a peak, not that the stock is underpriced."," Schwab says the same in general terms: a cyclical company's PE may fall significantly during an expansion, when earnings and margins tend to rise.",[61,557,559],{"id":558},"the-name-for-this-is-a-value-trap","The name for this is a value trap",[11,561,562],{},"A stock that looks cheap on a ratio and keeps getting cheaper is called a value trap. The low PE was real; the earnings behind it were temporary. Energy, at the bottom of the table above, is a sector to read the same way: FactSet tied part of its earnings growth in the third quarter of 2026 to an average oil price of $85.68, 32% above the year before.",[25,564,566],{"id":565},"myth-3-a-high-pe-ratio-means-a-stock-is-overpriced","Myth 3: A High PE Ratio Means a Stock Is Overpriced",[11,568,569],{},"This is the mirror image of myth 2. A high PE says investors pay a lot for today's earnings. It says nothing yet about next year's.",[11,571,572],{},"Nvidia shows the arithmetic. Its diluted earnings per share were $0.17 for the fiscal year ended January 29, 2023, and $1.19 for the year ended January 28, 2024, adjusted for its 2024 stock split, per Fiscal.ai's income statement data. Earnings per share grew seven times in one year. A share price that stood still through that year would have seen its trailing PE fall to a seventh of where it started.",[11,574,575,578],{},[17,576,577],{},"When earnings grow fast, a high trailing PE can shrink without the price falling at all."," The whole market showed a milder version in October 2026: Forbes reported that the S&P 500's forward PE had dropped to 19.1 while the index sat near record highs, because earnings grew much faster than prices.",[61,580,582],{"id":581},"the-peg-ratio-puts-growth-back-in","The PEG ratio puts growth back in",[11,584,585],{},"Peter Lynch wrote in One Up on Wall Street that the PE of any company that is fairly priced will equal its growth rate. That idea is the PEG ratio: the PE divided by the annual earnings growth rate. In Schwab's example, a forward PE of 20 with 10% expected earnings growth gives a PEG of 2.",[11,587,588],{},"PEG has its own weak spot. It leans on a growth estimate, and estimates change. A high PE is a question about growth, not a verdict on the price.",[25,590,592],{"id":591},"myth-4-every-stock-has-one-pe-ratio","Myth 4: Every Stock Has One PE Ratio",[11,594,595],{},"Look up the same stock on three sites and you may get three PE ratios. None of them has to be wrong; they divide by different earnings.",[11,597,598],{},"Trailing PE uses the last 12 months of reported earnings. Forward PE uses analysts' estimates for the next 12 months. An adjusted PE swaps reported earnings for the company's own non-GAAP figure, which usually leaves out costs the company calls one-time.",[11,600,601],{},"Here is how far apart those readings sat for the same index within one week:",[215,603,604,617],{},[218,605,606],{},[221,607,608,611,614],{},[224,609,610],{},"Measure for the S&P 500",[224,612,613],{},"Reading",[224,615,616],{},"Comparison",[234,618,619,629,640],{},[221,620,621,624,626],{},[239,622,623],{},"Forward 12-month PE, FactSet, Oct 30, 2026",[239,625,488],{},[239,627,628],{},"10-year average 19.1",[221,630,631,634,637],{},[239,632,633],{},"Trailing 12-month PE, FactSet, Oct 30, 2026",[239,635,636],{},"25.9",[239,638,639],{},"10-year average 23.7",[221,641,642,645,648],{},[239,643,644],{},"Shiller PE (CAPE), Multpl, Nov 6, 2026",[239,646,647],{},"38.91",[239,649,650],{},"Historical mean 17.45",[11,652,653],{},"Same market, three readings: below its average on the first, above it on the second, and more than double it on the third.",[61,655,657],{"id":656},"why-the-gaps-exist","Why the gaps exist",[11,659,660],{},"Forward PE comes out lower when analysts expect earnings to grow, and it is only as good as those estimates. Adjusted earnings have their critics too. FactSet notes that there is no industry-standard definition of non-GAAP EPS, and that companies can use the gap to exclude items that more often than not would have lowered earnings.",[11,662,663,664,669],{},"The ",[33,665,668],{"href":666,"target":36,"rel":667},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.multpl.com\u002Fshiller-pe",[38],"Shiller PE"," divides the price by ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings, which smooths out exactly the boom and bust that fooled the Micron reading. Its record is 44.19, set in December 1999.",[11,671,672],{},[17,673,674],{},"Before comparing two PE ratios, check that both divide by the same kind of earnings.",[25,676,678],{"id":677},"myth-5-the-pe-ratio-works-for-every-company","Myth 5: The PE Ratio Works for Every Company",[11,680,681],{},"A company that lost money has no meaningful PE. Schwab notes that when a company has no earnings or a net loss, its PE is usually listed as N\u002FA, and that the negative PE ratios some websites show are not useful for valuation.",[11,683,684],{},"Micron again: after its fiscal 2023 loss, its trailing PE stopped being a number worth reading at all. The ratio that had looked so cheap a year earlier now said nothing.",[11,686,687,688,692],{},"For loss-making companies, investors tend to switch to price to sales, which compares the price with revenue instead of earnings, or to cash measures. Our explainer on the ",[33,689,691],{"href":690},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Ffree-cash-flow-formula-when-earnings-and-cash-disagree","free cash flow formula"," shows why cash and earnings can tell different stories about the same quarter.",[11,694,695],{},[17,696,697],{},"A missing PE is not a warning or a bargain on its own; it means this tool does not fit this company right now.",[25,699,701],{"id":700},"how-to-read-a-pe-ratio-without-falling-for-the-myths","How to Read a PE Ratio Without Falling for the Myths",[11,703,704],{},"Five questions do most of the work, and each one answers a myth above:",[299,706,707,710,713,716,719],{},[302,708,709],{},"Which PE is it? Trailing, forward or adjusted, and measured on which date.",[302,711,712],{},"What do direct peers trade at? In the table above, sectors sat five points or more either side of the index.",[302,714,715],{},"What is the stock's own range? Compare it with its own readings over several years.",[302,717,718],{},"Where are earnings in their cycle? A low PE on peak earnings can be a trap, as Micron's 2022 reading showed.",[302,720,721],{},"How fast are earnings growing? A high PE on fast-growing earnings can shrink quickly, as Nvidia's did.",[61,723,317],{"id":316},[11,725,726],{},"Answering those questions for one stock means pulling prices, earnings and ratios from several pages. Primo Trade does part of that from a ticker: it pulls prices, news and financial metrics for a US-listed stock and runs one AI analysis over them. The result includes a Primo Score with a Fundamental score from 0 to 100, and Key Insights tagged fundamental when the AI sees something in the numbers worth flagging.",[11,728,729],{},"Treat that score as the AI's read of the data, not a verdict. A Fundamental score of 80 is not an 80% chance of anything, and the AI cannot know whether this year's earnings are a cyclical peak any better than the PE can. Primo Trade gives AI-generated analysis for information and education. It is not financial advice. Markets carry risk; do your own research before you trade.",[25,731,732],{"id":331},"The Short Version",[11,734,735],{},"The PE ratio is price divided by a year of earnings per share, and it is only as useful as the earnings underneath it. Under 15 is not automatically cheap, and over 30 is not automatically expensive.",[11,737,738],{},"A low PE on peak earnings, as Micron showed in 2022, can come right before a loss. A high PE on fast-growing earnings, as Nvidia showed, can fall without the price moving. Check which PE you are reading, compare it with the sector and the stock's own past, and ask where its earnings sit in their cycle.",{"title":337,"searchDepth":338,"depth":338,"links":740},[741,742,745,749,752,755,756,759],{"id":396,"depth":338,"text":397},{"id":423,"depth":338,"text":424,"children":743},[744],{"id":510,"depth":344,"text":511},{"id":522,"depth":338,"text":523,"children":746},[747,748],{"id":538,"depth":344,"text":539},{"id":558,"depth":344,"text":559},{"id":565,"depth":338,"text":566,"children":750},[751],{"id":581,"depth":344,"text":582},{"id":591,"depth":338,"text":592,"children":753},[754],{"id":656,"depth":344,"text":657},{"id":677,"depth":338,"text":678},{"id":700,"depth":338,"text":701,"children":757},[758],{"id":316,"depth":344,"text":317},{"id":331,"depth":338,"text":732},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fpe-ratio-five-myths-about-cheap-and-expensive-stocks.jpg","PE ratio myths that mislead investors: why under 15 is not automatically cheap, why Micron looked cheapest at its 2022 peak, and which PE you are reading.",{},"\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fpe-ratio-five-myths-about-cheap-and-expensive-stocks","2026-11-08",{"title":382,"description":761},{"loc":763,"images":767},[768],{"loc":548},"blog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fpe-ratio-five-myths-about-cheap-and-expensive-stocks","cD86tLKwsIDl2NGRWdF_QicT-dDASs0wAr8irOB31LU",{"id":772,"title":773,"author":6,"body":774,"coverImg":1139,"description":1140,"extension":368,"head":6,"meta":1141,"navigation":370,"path":1142,"publishedAt":1143,"schemaOrg":6,"seo":1144,"sitemap":1145,"stem":1148,"updatedAt":6,"__hash__":1149},"blog\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fengulfing-candle-bullish-vs-bearish-and-where-each-fails.md","Engulfing Candle: Bullish vs Bearish and Where Each Fails",{"type":8,"value":775,"toc":1118},[776,779,782,785,789,792,874,887,890,894,897,903,909,915,922,926,935,938,942,946,949,952,955,959,962,969,973,976,985,988,992,995,998,1002,1005,1009,1012,1032,1035,1039,1042,1049,1053,1056,1060,1063,1067,1076,1079,1082,1085,1089,1092,1095,1097,1105,1109,1112,1115],[11,777,778],{},"A stock has slid for a week. Then one session opens below yesterday's close, buyers take over, and by the bell a tall green candle has swallowed the small red one before it. Someone in the chat posts the screenshot with one word: engulfing.",[11,780,781],{},"An engulfing candle is a two-candle pattern in which the second candle's body completely covers the first candle's body and closes in the opposite direction. After a decline, a green body covering a red one is a bullish engulfing pattern. After a rise, a red body covering a green one is a bearish engulfing pattern. In Thomas Bulkowski's testing on US stocks, the bearish version reversed the trend 79% of the time and the bullish version 63%.",[11,783,784],{},"Those two numbers are where most write-ups stop, and they hide the more useful part. Both patterns ranked near the bottom of 103 candlesticks for how far price travelled after the break. This guide puts the two side by side, shows the lookalikes that fool people, and walks through where each one tends to fail.",[25,786,788],{"id":787},"bullish-vs-bearish-engulfing-at-a-glance","Bullish vs Bearish Engulfing at a Glance",[11,790,791],{},"Here are the two patterns next to each other, with Bulkowski's measured figures. His ranks run from 1, the best, to 103.",[215,793,794,806],{},[218,795,796],{},[221,797,798,800,803],{},[224,799],{},[224,801,802],{},"Bullish engulfing",[224,804,805],{},"Bearish engulfing",[234,807,808,819,830,841,852,863],{},[221,809,810,813,816],{},[239,811,812],{},"Trend leading in",[239,814,815],{},"Down",[239,817,818],{},"Up",[221,820,821,824,827],{},[239,822,823],{},"The two candles",[239,825,826],{},"Red, then a taller green",[239,828,829],{},"Green, then a taller red",[221,831,832,835,838],{},[239,833,834],{},"Acted as a reversal",[239,836,837],{},"63% of the time",[239,839,840],{},"79% of the time",[221,842,843,846,849],{},[239,844,845],{},"Rank for reversal rate",[239,847,848],{},"22",[239,850,851],{},"5",[221,853,854,857,860],{},[239,855,856],{},"Rank for performance after the break",[239,858,859],{},"84",[239,861,862],{},"91",[221,864,865,868,871],{},[239,866,867],{},"Rank for how often it appears",[239,869,870],{},"12",[239,872,873],{},"11",[11,875,876,877,880,881,886],{},"Read the last three rows together. ",[17,878,879],{},"Both patterns turn price often and push it a short way."," Bulkowski's pages on the ",[33,882,885],{"href":883,"target":36,"rel":884},"https:\u002F\u002Fthepatternsite.com\u002FBullEngulfing.html",[38],"bullish engulfing"," and the bearish one put it bluntly: the bearish engulfing \"does not imply a lasting reversal\", and the bullish version's post-breakout performance \"can be dreadful\".",[11,888,889],{},"The sample matters too. Bulkowski built his candlestick research on more than 4.7 million daily price bars from hundreds of US stocks, with data going back to the 1980s, and the bearish engulfing figure alone comes from roughly 20,000 patterns. These are averages from a past sample, not odds for the next chart you see.",[25,891,893],{"id":892},"what-an-engulfing-candle-is-and-what-it-ignores","What an Engulfing Candle Is, and What It Ignores",[11,895,896],{},"Three things make an engulfing candle, and all three get bent in practice.",[11,898,899,902],{},[17,900,901],{},"The trend before it."," A bullish engulfing needs a downtrend leading in, and a bearish engulfing needs an uptrend. The same two candles in the wrong trend are a different pattern with a different track record, which the failure section below covers.",[11,904,905,908],{},[17,906,907],{},"Bodies, not wicks."," The second body has to cover the first body. The shadows do not count. Bulkowski's identification notes say \"ignore the shadows\", and his definition allows the tops or the bottoms of the two bodies to sit at the same price, but not both.",[11,910,911,914],{},[17,912,913],{},"The open beyond the prior close."," For a bullish engulfing, the green candle opens below the red candle's close and closes above the red candle's open. For a bearish engulfing, the red candle opens above the green close and closes below the green open. On a daily stock chart that means the second session opened beyond the first session's close before running the other way.",[11,916,663,917,921],{},[33,918,920],{"href":919},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fhow-to-read-candlestick-charts","guide to reading candlestick charts"," covers the four prices inside every candle, if the body and wick distinction is new.",[61,923,925],{"id":924},"engulfing-candle-vs-outside-day","Engulfing candle vs outside day",[11,927,928,929,934],{},"The pattern people most often mistake for an engulfing candle is the outside day, sometimes called an outside reversal. The ",[33,930,933],{"href":931,"target":36,"rel":932},"https:\u002F\u002Fchartschool.stockcharts.com\u002Ftable-of-contents\u002Fchart-analysis\u002Fcandlestick-charts\u002Fcandlestick-pattern-dictionary",[38],"StockCharts candlestick dictionary"," draws the line clearly: an outside reversal needs the whole range, high and low, to be covered, while an engulfing pattern needs only the open and close.",[11,936,937],{},"So the two overlap without being the same. A candle can engulf the prior body and still leave the prior wick poking out above or below it. Another can cover the whole prior range, wicks included, with a body that does not cover the prior body. When someone shares a chart and calls it engulfing, check the bodies first.",[162,939],{"src":940,"alt":941,"width":166,"height":167},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fengulfing-candle-bullish-vs-bearish-and-where-each-fails\u002Fengulfing-vs-outside-day.jpg","Diagram comparing a bullish engulfing pair, where the green body covers the red body while a red wick still sticks out, with an outside day, where the green candle's full range covers the prior candle's range.",[25,943,945],{"id":944},"the-bullish-engulfing-candle-turns-often-travels-little","The Bullish Engulfing Candle: Turns Often, Travels Little",[11,947,948],{},"The bullish engulfing candle looks like the cleaner signal of the two. The bears push price lower on day one, day two opens lower still, and then buyers take the whole session back and more.",[11,950,951],{},"Bulkowski measured it as a bullish reversal 63% of the time, meaning price closed above the top of the two-candle pattern before it closed below the bottom. That ranks 22nd of 103 patterns. In the same body of work he called anything under 60% \"random or nearly so\", so the bullish engulfing clears his bar by three points.",[11,953,954],{},"The weak spot is what happens after the break. Its overall performance rank is 84 of 103. Bulkowski's notes say that even the best of its upward-breakout cases showed price 1.18% lower ten days later on average, where a working bullish pattern would normally show a rise. His conclusion is that the pattern did its best work in bear markets and after downward breakouts, which is the opposite of what the name promises.",[61,956,958],{"id":957},"where-the-bullish-engulfing-did-better","Where the bullish engulfing did better",[11,960,961],{},"His trading notes for the pattern point to three conditions. Bullish engulfing candles that appeared within a third of the yearly low did better than the rest. Tall candles did better than short ones. And the ones to avoid were those that formed inside a downward primary trend.",[11,963,964,965,968],{},"That last point needs a picture. A bullish engulfing can show up in the middle of a long decline and lift price for a few days, and then the bigger downtrend takes over again. ",[17,966,967],{},"Bulkowski's own preference was a bullish engulfing in a pullback inside a rising primary trend",", where the reversal lines up with the larger direction rather than fighting it.",[25,970,972],{"id":971},"the-bearish-engulfing-candle-top-reversal-rate-short-follow-through","The Bearish Engulfing Candle: Top Reversal Rate, Short Follow-Through",[11,974,975],{},"The bearish engulfing is the mirror image: in an uptrend, a green candle is followed by a taller red one that opens above the green close and finishes below the green open.",[11,977,978,979,984],{},"On reversal rate it is one of the strongest candles Bulkowski tested. On the ",[33,980,983],{"href":981,"target":36,"rel":982},"https:\u002F\u002Fthepatternsite.com\u002FBearEngulfing.html",[38],"bearish engulfing page"," he reports a bearish reversal 79% of the time, ranking 5th of 103, from about 20,000 patterns. His Stocks and Commodities article on the best-behaved candles gives the same 79% for bull markets.",[11,986,987],{},"Then comes the catch. For performance after the break it ranks 91st. The split by breakout direction explains why: after an upward breakout, the cases where the pattern failed, it ranked 103rd and 100th in bull and bear markets. After a downward breakout it ranked 25th and 21st. The bearish engulfing usually turns price, and when it does not, the move against it is among the worst of any candle.",[61,989,991],{"id":990},"where-the-bearish-engulfing-did-better","Where the bearish engulfing did better",[11,993,994],{},"Bulkowski's notes for the bearish version are less intuitive. The ones that formed within a third of the yearly low did better than those near the high. In his article on when candles work best, a bearish engulfing in a bear market with a downward breakout averaged an 11.7% decline when it closed in the lowest third of the yearly range, against 9.4% for the middle third and 10.2% for the top third.",[11,996,997],{},"His other two notes match the bullish version: tall candles did better, and the setup he favoured was a bounce inside a falling primary trend. A bearish engulfing at the top of a short rally in a stock that is already in a downtrend lines up with the bigger move. One at the top of a strong uptrend is fighting it.",[25,999,1001],{"id":1000},"where-each-one-fails","Where Each One Fails",[11,1003,1004],{},"The averages above hide the cases that go wrong. Most failures come from four situations, and they apply to both versions.",[61,1006,1008],{"id":1007},"the-right-shape-in-the-wrong-trend","The right shape in the wrong trend",[11,1010,1011],{},"The same two candles mean something else when the trend leading in is reversed. Bulkowski tested these lookalikes as separate patterns:",[299,1013,1014,1020,1026],{},[302,1015,1016,1019],{},[17,1017,1018],{},"Last engulfing bottom",": a green candle followed by a red one that engulfs it, in a downtrend. It is supposed to be a bullish reversal and acted as a bearish continuation 65% of the time.",[302,1021,1022,1025],{},[17,1023,1024],{},"Last engulfing top",": a red candle followed by a green one that engulfs it, in an uptrend. Supposed to be bearish, it acted as a bullish continuation 68% of the time.",[302,1027,1028,1031],{},[17,1029,1030],{},"Bullish engulfing inside a long decline",": the shape is right and the short-term trend is right, but the primary trend is down, and his example shows the bounce fading as the decline resumes.",[11,1033,1034],{},"The lesson is that colour and size alone do not define the pattern. A red candle swallowing a green one at a low is not a bearish engulfing, and it did not behave like one.",[61,1036,1038],{"id":1037},"no-confirmation-from-the-next-session","No confirmation from the next session",[11,1040,1041],{},"An engulfing pair completes at the close of day two, and Bulkowski measured reversal from the first close beyond the pattern. Some traders wait for that close, and the three-candle versions formalise it: three outside up is a bullish engulfing followed by a higher close, and three outside down is a bearish engulfing followed by a lower close. He measured them as reversals 75% and 69% of the time in bull markets.",[11,1043,1044,1045,1048],{},"He also tested three ways to confirm any candle pattern: the next close, the next candle's colour and an opening gap in the expected direction. The opening gap came first in 82% of cases, candle colour in 13% and the closing price in 5%. ",[17,1046,1047],{},"A gap in the expected direction at the next open was the earliest confirmation in most cases",", and an open in the other direction is an early hint that the pattern may not hold.",[61,1050,1052],{"id":1051},"volume-inside-the-pattern","Volume inside the pattern",[11,1054,1055],{},"A tall engulfing candle on heavy volume looks more convincing. Bulkowski's numbers say it barely matters. Above-average volume inside a candle pattern was linked to better performance 58% of the time, close to random. What did separate the results was volume on the breakout day: in 91% of candle types, patterns with heavy breakout-day volume did better than those with light volume.",[61,1057,1059],{"id":1058},"expecting-a-big-move","Expecting a big move",[11,1061,1062],{},"A high reversal rate tells you price often turned. It says nothing about how far. Both engulfing patterns rank in the bottom quarter of 103 for performance after the break, so a reading that expects a lasting trend change from one engulfing pair is asking more of it than the record shows.",[25,1064,1066],{"id":1065},"what-a-test-on-the-sp-500-found","What a Test on the S&P 500 Found",[11,1068,1069,1070,1075],{},"A separate test by ",[33,1071,1074],{"href":1072,"target":36,"rel":1073},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.cxoadvisory.com\u002Ftechnical-trading\u002Ftesting-engulfing-candlesticks\u002F",[38],"CXO Advisory"," looked at engulfing candles on the S&P 500 index from January 1962 to July 2010. It used a stricter, range-based definition: the second day had a higher high and a lower low than the first and closed in the top quarter of its range for bullish, or the bottom quarter for bearish. That is closer to the outside day than to the body rule above, which is worth keeping in mind.",[11,1077,1078],{},"It found 186 bullish and 184 bearish patterns over 48 years. Both pointed the right way for the first trading day after they formed, and the effect was weaker after 1990. Over the next 20 trading days the first-day move did not clearly persist.",[11,1080,1081],{},"The 200-day moving average changed the picture. The bullish pattern looked better when the index was below its 200-day average, with 65 such cases since 1962. After a bearish engulfing with the index above its 200-day average, the index tended to keep rising rather than fall. CXO's summary was that the signals were small, rare and noisy, and that it seemed unlikely a trader could exploit them at the portfolio level.",[11,1083,1084],{},"That fits Bulkowski's picture from a different angle. The candle often marks a short turn; the trend around it decides what happens next.",[25,1086,1088],{"id":1087},"reading-an-engulfing-candle-with-primo-trade","Reading an Engulfing Candle With Primo Trade",[11,1090,1091],{},"The questions this post keeps returning to are about context: what the trend was before the pair, where it sits in the recent range, and what the next session did. Those are the parts a single screenshot in a group chat rarely shows.",[11,1093,1094],{},"Primo Trade's Analyze Chart works from a photo or screenshot of a chart. The AI reads the trend, volatility, volume and sentiment, names the chart pattern it sees and explains what that pattern usually signals. That makes it a second read on the trend leading into an engulfing pair, not a verdict on where price goes next. If the AI reads a US ticker off the image, the full ticker analysis runs, with a signal, Primo Score and Trading Strategy beside the chart read.",[11,1096,328],{},[11,1098,1099,1100,1104],{},"A screenshot holds only the candles in frame. Whether an engulfing pair sits near the yearly low depends on how much history you capture, so a wider view gives any reader, human or AI, more to work with. The ",[33,1101,1103],{"href":1102},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fcandlestick-patterns-cheat-sheet","candlestick patterns cheat sheet"," puts the engulfing pair next to the other common shapes on one page.",[25,1106,1108],{"id":1107},"the-bottom-line","The Bottom Line",[11,1110,1111],{},"An engulfing candle is a second body that covers the first and closes the other way. After a decline it is bullish, after a rise bearish, and the wicks do not count.",[11,1113,1114],{},"In Bulkowski's data on US stocks, the bearish engulfing reversed the trend 79% of the time and the bullish engulfing 63%, yet both ranked in the bottom quarter of 103 patterns for how far price travelled afterwards. A test on the S&P 500 from 1962 to 2010 found a first-day effect that faded within days.",[11,1116,1117],{},"Most failures came from the same few places: the right shape in the wrong trend, a pair fighting the primary trend, no confirmation at the next open, and the expectation of a big move from a pattern that measured as a short turn. Read the trend first, the bodies second, and the next open third.",{"title":337,"searchDepth":338,"depth":338,"links":1119},[1120,1121,1124,1127,1130,1136,1137,1138],{"id":787,"depth":338,"text":788},{"id":892,"depth":338,"text":893,"children":1122},[1123],{"id":924,"depth":344,"text":925},{"id":944,"depth":338,"text":945,"children":1125},[1126],{"id":957,"depth":344,"text":958},{"id":971,"depth":338,"text":972,"children":1128},[1129],{"id":990,"depth":344,"text":991},{"id":1000,"depth":338,"text":1001,"children":1131},[1132,1133,1134,1135],{"id":1007,"depth":344,"text":1008},{"id":1037,"depth":344,"text":1038},{"id":1051,"depth":344,"text":1052},{"id":1058,"depth":344,"text":1059},{"id":1065,"depth":338,"text":1066},{"id":1087,"depth":338,"text":1088},{"id":1107,"depth":338,"text":1108},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fengulfing-candle-bullish-vs-bearish-and-where-each-fails.jpg","Engulfing candle, tested: bearish engulfing reversed 79% of the time, bullish 63%, yet both ranked low for what came next. Where each one fails.",{},"\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fengulfing-candle-bullish-vs-bearish-and-where-each-fails","2026-11-12",{"title":773,"description":1140},{"loc":1142,"images":1146},[1147],{"loc":940},"blog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fengulfing-candle-bullish-vs-bearish-and-where-each-fails","uh6roa3iVf29f5vuIbG3s_odBlq2DWgZibm2Sf_1t8Q",{"id":1151,"title":1152,"author":6,"body":1153,"coverImg":1502,"description":1503,"extension":368,"head":6,"meta":1504,"navigation":370,"path":1505,"publishedAt":1506,"schemaOrg":6,"seo":1507,"sitemap":1508,"stem":1511,"updatedAt":6,"__hash__":1512},"blog\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fprice-to-book-ratio-how-intel-fell-below-its-book-value.md","Price to Book Ratio: How Intel Fell Below Its Book Value",{"type":8,"value":1154,"toc":1487},[1155,1158,1161,1165,1168,1171,1177,1181,1184,1188,1197,1251,1259,1263,1269,1277,1286,1290,1293,1296,1299,1305,1309,1318,1332,1335,1339,1342,1397,1403,1407,1410,1413,1416,1420,1424,1433,1436,1439,1442,1446,1449,1466,1469,1471,1474,1478,1481,1484],[11,1156,1157],{},"On August 2, 2024, Intel shares fell 26% to $21.48 in a single session. By the close, one share cost less than the accounting value of what that share owned. The price to book ratio, the share price divided by book value per share, had dropped to about 0.8, which a screener reads as \"trading below book\".",[11,1159,1160],{},"That phrase sounds like a bargain. This post reads the window after the fact, from Intel's August 1, 2024 earnings release to the deals of September 2025, using Intel's own filings: what the ratio said that Friday, what happened to the \"book\" half of it three months later, and what no balance sheet could have shown.",[25,1162,1164],{"id":1163},"what-the-price-to-book-ratio-measures","What the Price to Book Ratio Measures",[11,1166,1167],{},"Book value is what is left when you subtract everything a company owes from everything it owns. On a balance sheet it is called stockholders' equity. Divide it by the shares outstanding and you get book value per share; divide the share price by that and you get the price to book ratio, written P\u002FB.",[11,1169,1170],{},"A P\u002FB of 1 means the market prices the company at exactly its accounting net worth. Above 1, buyers are paying for something the balance sheet does not carry: future earnings, a brand, a technology lead. Below 1, the market is saying the books overstate what the assets are worth, or that the business will eat into them.",[11,1172,1173,1176],{},[17,1174,1175],{},"The ratio is only as reliable as its denominator, and the denominator is an accounting estimate, not a price."," Factories sit on the books at cost minus depreciation. Goodwill sits at what was paid for an acquisition. Tax assets sit at what the company expects to use. Any of these can be marked down in a single quarter, and in Intel's case several were.",[61,1178,1180],{"id":1179},"the-formula-in-one-line","The formula in one line",[11,1182,1183],{},"P\u002FB = share price ÷ (equity attributable to the company ÷ shares outstanding). The middle step matters. Many companies report a total equity figure that includes non-controlling interests, the slices of subsidiaries owned by outsiders, and those slices do not belong to the shareholders whose price you are dividing.",[25,1185,1187],{"id":1186},"intels-book-value-before-the-drop","Intel's Book Value Before the Drop",[11,1189,1190,1191,1196],{},"The last balance sheet before the earnings release was dated June 29, 2024. Intel's next quarterly ",[33,1192,1195],{"href":1193,"target":36,"rel":1194},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.sec.gov\u002FArchives\u002Fedgar\u002Fdata\u002F50863\u002F000005086324000149\u002Fintc-20240928.htm",[38],"SEC filing"," for the following quarter restates it: total stockholders' equity of $120.4 billion, of which $5.2 billion belonged to non-controlling interests. That leaves $115.2 billion for Intel's own shareholders, spread over 4,276 million shares.",[215,1198,1199,1209],{},[218,1200,1201],{},[221,1202,1203,1206],{},[224,1204,1205],{},"Item",[224,1207,1208],{},"Value",[234,1210,1211,1219,1227,1235,1243],{},[221,1212,1213,1216],{},[239,1214,1215],{},"Equity attributable to Intel, June 29, 2024",[239,1217,1218],{},"$115.2 billion",[221,1220,1221,1224],{},[239,1222,1223],{},"Shares outstanding",[239,1225,1226],{},"4,276 million",[221,1228,1229,1232],{},[239,1230,1231],{},"Book value per share",[239,1233,1234],{},"$26.95",[221,1236,1237,1240],{},[239,1238,1239],{},"Close on August 2, 2024",[239,1241,1242],{},"$21.48",[221,1244,1245,1248],{},[239,1246,1247],{},"Price to book ratio",[239,1249,1250],{},"0.80",[11,1252,1253,1254,1258],{},"Multiply the close by the share count and the market was valuing all of Intel at about $92 billion, roughly $23 billion less than its own books said the company was worth. The same equity figure is the denominator of the ",[33,1255,1257],{"href":1256},"https:\u002F\u002Fprimotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fdebt-to-equity-ratio-how-to-calculate-and-read-it","debt to equity ratio",", so anything that shrinks it moves both ratios at once.",[25,1260,1262],{"id":1261},"why-intel-fell-below-book-value-in-one-day","Why Intel Fell Below Book Value in One Day",[11,1264,1265,1266,1268],{},"The trigger was the second-quarter report, released after the close on August 1. Revenue was $12.8 billion, down 1% from a year earlier. The GAAP net loss attributable to Intel was $1.6 billion, or $0.38 a share, while the non-GAAP figure showed a profit of $0.02 a share; that gap between two versions of one quarter is the subject of our post on ",[33,1267,419],{"href":418},".",[11,1270,1271,1272,1268],{},"The same release announced a $10 billion cost reduction plan, a headcount cut of more than 15%, and the suspension of the dividend from the fourth quarter. CEO Pat Gelsinger called the results \"disappointing\", and the CFO named \"the impact from unused capacity\" among the reasons margins fell, according to Intel's ",[33,1273,1276],{"href":1274,"target":36,"rel":1275},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.intc.com\u002Fnews-events\u002Fpress-releases\u002Fdetail\u002F1704\u002Fintel-reports-second-quarter-2024-financial-results",[38],"second-quarter release",[11,1278,1279,1280,1285],{},"The next day the stock had its ",[33,1281,1284],{"href":1282,"target":36,"rel":1283},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.reuters.com\u002Ftechnology\u002Fintel-shares-set-fall-most-24-years-it-struggles-with-turnaround-2024-08-02",[38],"worst day"," since 1974, as Reuters put it, closing at a price CNBC noted had not been seen since 2013.",[25,1287,1289],{"id":1288},"price-to-book-ratio-below-1-two-readings-at-the-time","Price to Book Ratio Below 1: Two Readings at the Time",[11,1291,1292],{},"On the afternoon of August 2, a P\u002FB of 0.80 supported two stories, and the number alone could not choose between them.",[11,1294,1295],{},"The first is the value reading. The factories, the patents and the cash on the books are worth more than the market is paying, the selloff is an overreaction, and the gap closes when sentiment turns.",[11,1297,1298],{},"The second is the trap reading. The assets are not worth what the books say, or the business will lose money using them until the equity is smaller than it looks. In that story the price is not below book value; the book value is above reality, and the filings have not caught up.",[11,1300,1301,1304],{},[17,1302,1303],{},"What separates the two is whether the assets earn."," Intel's GAAP operating margin for the quarter was minus 15.3%, and its own CFO pointed at unused capacity. A company losing money on its assets tends to shrink its equity quarter by quarter, through losses, write-downs, or both. That does not prove the trap reading. It does mean the denominator of the ratio was under pressure on the day the ratio looked cheapest.",[25,1306,1308],{"id":1307},"three-months-later-the-book-shrank","Three Months Later, the Book Shrank",[11,1310,1311,1312,1317],{},"On October 31, 2024, Intel reported its third quarter. Revenue was $13.3 billion. The net loss attributable to Intel was $16.6 billion, or $3.88 a share, and the ",[33,1313,1316],{"href":1314,"target":36,"rel":1315},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.intc.com\u002Fnews-events\u002Fpress-releases\u002Fdetail\u002F1716\u002Fintel-reports-third-quarter-2024-financial-results",[38],"third-quarter release"," listed what drove it:",[299,1319,1320,1323,1326,1329],{},[302,1321,1322],{},"$9.9 billion of non-cash charges to set up a valuation allowance against US deferred tax assets",[302,1324,1325],{},"$2.9 billion of goodwill and intangible asset impairments, mainly for the Mobileye reporting unit",[302,1327,1328],{},"$3.1 billion of impairments and accelerated depreciation on manufacturing assets, mostly the Intel 7 process node",[302,1330,1331],{},"$2.8 billion of restructuring charges, $2.2 billion of which will be paid in cash later",[11,1333,1334],{},"A deferred tax asset is the value of future tax savings, and it only counts if the company expects taxable profits to use it against. Intel wrote it down \"due to a historical cumulative loss\". In plain terms, part of the book value was a bet on future profits, and the accountants stopped counting it.",[61,1336,1338],{"id":1337},"the-same-price-against-the-new-book","The same price against the new book",[11,1340,1341],{},"At September 28, 2024, equity attributable to Intel was $99.5 billion over 4,309 million shares.",[215,1343,1344,1357],{},[218,1345,1346],{},[221,1347,1348,1351,1354],{},[224,1349,1350],{},"Measure",[224,1352,1353],{},"June 29, 2024",[224,1355,1356],{},"Sept 28, 2024",[234,1358,1359,1369,1378,1387],{},[221,1360,1361,1364,1366],{},[239,1362,1363],{},"Equity attributable to Intel",[239,1365,1218],{},[239,1367,1368],{},"$99.5 billion",[221,1370,1371,1373,1375],{},[239,1372,1223],{},[239,1374,1226],{},[239,1376,1377],{},"4,309 million",[221,1379,1380,1382,1384],{},[239,1381,1231],{},[239,1383,1234],{},[239,1385,1386],{},"$23.10",[221,1388,1389,1392,1394],{},[239,1390,1391],{},"P\u002FB at the $21.48 close of Aug 2",[239,1393,1250],{},[239,1395,1396],{},"0.93",[11,1398,1399,1402],{},[17,1400,1401],{},"Hold the price still and the discount to book fell from 20% to 7%, without the stock moving a cent."," About $15.7 billion of equity attributable to Intel had gone. Most of the quarter's loss came from non-cash charges against value that exists on paper until it is tested: tax assets, goodwill, the carrying value of a process node the market wanted less of.",[25,1404,1406],{"id":1405},"tangible-book-value-the-stricter-test","Tangible Book Value: The Stricter Test",[11,1408,1409],{},"Some readers skip that argument by using tangible book value: equity minus goodwill and identified intangible assets. Goodwill is the premium paid over the assets in past acquisitions, and it cannot be sold on its own.",[11,1411,1412],{},"At September 28, 2024, Intel carried $24.7 billion of goodwill and $4.0 billion of identified intangibles. Take them out and tangible book value was $70.9 billion, or $16.45 a share. Against the August 2 close of $21.48, that is a price to tangible book ratio of about 1.31.",[11,1414,1415],{},"Measured on what Intel could physically point to, the stock was never below book in this window. The \"below book\" headline depended on which book you used, and the one in the screener was the softest version.",[162,1417],{"src":1418,"alt":1419,"width":166,"height":167},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fprice-to-book-ratio-how-intel-fell-below-its-book-value\u002Fprice-and-book-value.jpg","Diagram of a falling market price line crossing below a book value line that then steps down after a write-down",[25,1421,1423],{"id":1422},"what-followed-events-no-balance-sheet-showed","What Followed: Events No Balance Sheet Showed",[11,1425,1426,1427,1432],{},"A year later the story moved for reasons that sat in no 2024 filing. On August 22, 2025, Intel announced that the ",[33,1428,1431],{"href":1429,"target":36,"rel":1430},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.intc.com\u002Fnews-events\u002Fpress-releases\u002Fdetail\u002F1748\u002Fintel-and-trump-administration-reach-historic-agreement-to",[38],"US government"," would buy 433.3 million new shares at $20.47 each, a 9.9% stake funded by $5.7 billion of CHIPS Act grants not yet paid and $3.2 billion from the Secure Enclave program. Reuters put the price about $4 below that day's close of $24.80.",[11,1434,1435],{},"On September 18, 2025, Nvidia agreed to invest $5 billion in Intel at $23.28 a share, below the previous close of $24.90, and Reuters reported in December 2025 that the stake had been taken.",[11,1437,1438],{},"Two details are worth sitting with. The government's price of $20.47 was below the $21.48 close on the day Intel first fell below book. And the government deal created 433.3 million new shares, so the share count in the denominator grew; when new shares are sold below book value per share, each existing share's slice of the book gets thinner.",[11,1440,1441],{},"None of this was visible to a P\u002FB reading in August 2024. The ratio said the market doubted the books. The next quarter showed the market was partly right about the books. What came after turned on policy and a partnership, which no ratio of price to equity measures.",[25,1443,1445],{"id":1444},"how-to-read-a-low-price-to-book-ratio-in-your-own-research","How to Read a Low Price to Book Ratio in Your Own Research",[11,1447,1448],{},"A P\u002FB under 1 is a question, not an answer. Intel's window suggests five checks before the ratio means anything:",[299,1450,1451,1454,1457,1460,1463],{},[302,1452,1453],{},"Use equity attributable to the company, not total equity with non-controlling interests.",[302,1455,1456],{},"Look at what the book is made of: cash and factories, or goodwill, intangibles and deferred tax assets.",[302,1458,1459],{},"Ask whether the assets earn, through the operating margin and any talk of unused capacity.",[302,1461,1462],{},"Compare the ratio with the company's own history and its industry, not with 1.",[302,1464,1465],{},"Read the next quarterly filing for write-downs before trusting the denominator.",[11,1467,1468],{},"When you run a ticker analysis in Primo Trade, the AI reads financial metrics alongside prices and recent news, and the Fundamental score inside the Primo Score is its 0 to 100 read of that side of the business. A score is a summary, not a book value calculation. It will not tell you that a quarter of the equity is goodwill, so the filing is still where that answer lives.",[11,1470,328],{},[11,1472,1473],{},"A chart photo carries none of this. Analyze Chart reads the trend, volatility, volume and pattern in the image, and a balance sheet is not on a chart, unless the AI reads a US ticker off the picture and runs the full ticker analysis instead.",[25,1475,1477],{"id":1476},"what-intels-price-to-book-ratio-taught","What Intel's Price to Book Ratio Taught",[11,1479,1480],{},"Intel's P\u002FB fell to about 0.80 on August 2, 2024, when a 26% drop put the share price below $26.95 of book value per share. Within one quarter, $15.7 billion of write-downs and charges cut that book to $23.10 a share, and the same price looked far less cheap.",[11,1482,1483],{},"On tangible book, which strips out goodwill and intangibles, the stock never traded below book in this window at all. And the events that moved the stock a year later, a government stake and an Nvidia investment, were outside anything the ratio could measure.",[11,1485,1486],{},"The ratio is worth reading. The denominator is worth reading more closely, because in a business that is losing money on its assets, book value is the number most likely to change next.",{"title":337,"searchDepth":338,"depth":338,"links":1488},[1489,1492,1493,1494,1495,1498,1499,1500,1501],{"id":1163,"depth":338,"text":1164,"children":1490},[1491],{"id":1179,"depth":344,"text":1180},{"id":1186,"depth":338,"text":1187},{"id":1261,"depth":338,"text":1262},{"id":1288,"depth":338,"text":1289},{"id":1307,"depth":338,"text":1308,"children":1496},[1497],{"id":1337,"depth":344,"text":1338},{"id":1405,"depth":338,"text":1406},{"id":1422,"depth":338,"text":1423},{"id":1444,"depth":338,"text":1445},{"id":1476,"depth":338,"text":1477},"https:\u002F\u002Fmedia.primotrade.app\u002Fblog\u002Fprice-to-book-ratio-how-intel-fell-below-its-book-value.jpg","Price to book ratio through Intel in 2024: how the stock fell below book value, why the book then shrank, and what the ratio could not show.",{},"\u002Fblog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fprice-to-book-ratio-how-intel-fell-below-its-book-value","2026-11-14",{"title":1152,"description":1503},{"loc":1505,"images":1509},[1510],{"loc":1418},"blog\u002F2026\u002F11\u002Fprice-to-book-ratio-how-intel-fell-below-its-book-value","m6ovV_ovwh2iMrZWI53tcrpdBe9Zg8bpQPiTH3thjU4",1794742770102]