Simply Wall St Review: What the Snowflake Actually Checks

Simply Wall St Review: What the Snowflake Actually Checks

You open a company report, see a fat green snowflake and a line saying the stock trades well below fair value, and the question arrives on its own: what is that built on? This Simply Wall St review answers it. The Snowflake is 30 pass or fail checks drawn as a shape, and the fair value behind its valuation arm is a discounted cash flow model whose answer moves a lot with its assumptions. That makes Simply Wall St a fast first pass on a company's numbers, and a poor last word on what a share is worth.

Below is how the checks are scored, what the fair value number rests on, what the free and paid plans let you do, and who the tool suits. Every plan detail was read from Simply Wall St's own pages on 22 November 2026.

What Simply Wall St Is

Simply Wall St is a stock research site and app from Sydney that turns financial statements into visual reports. Its own plans page describes the scale as 7 million investors, more than 120,000 stocks and over 90 markets, with company data from S&P Global.

The focus is fundamentals over the long run: valuation, growth, past results, balance sheet and dividends. There is no charting workspace for intraday trading, and the reports read a company's filings and analyst forecasts rather than its price action.

Each company gets a report, a set of portfolio tools, a screener and community narratives where users post their own valuation stories. The Snowflake sits at the top of every report as the summary of all of it.

How the Simply Wall St Snowflake Scores a Stock

The scoring method is public. Simply Wall St publishes it as a model document in its company analysis model, and the rules are short.

There are five assessment areas: Value, Future Growth, Past Performance, Financial Health and Dividends. Each area runs six checks, so every stock faces 30. A pass scores one point and a fail scores zero, which gives each area a score from 0 to 6.

Those five scores set the shape. A high score pushes that arm of the Snowflake outward, and the more checks a company passes in total, the greener the whole shape turns. Fewer passes make it smaller and redder.

Diagram of a five-pointed radar shape with axes labelled Value, Future Growth, Past Performance, Financial Health and Dividends

Why Two Snowflakes Can Look Alike for Different Reasons

A score of 4 out of 6 tells you how many checks passed, not which ones. Two companies with the same Financial Health arm can be strong for different reasons, one on short-term liquidity, the other on low debt.

The checks are also binary. A stock that misses a threshold by a hair scores the same zero as one that misses it by a mile, so a small change in a reported number can move an arm a full step. The shape is a table of contents for the report, and the reasons live one click deeper.

The Fair Value Number Behind the Value Arm

The Value arm leans on one figure more than any other: fair value. The help center's guide to the valuation section lists six valuation checks. Two are intrinsic: a stock passes one check if its price sits below the fair value estimate, and a second if it sits at least 20% below. The other four compare valuation ratios with the market and the industry, and the price with analysts' price targets.

Fair value comes from a discounted cash flow model. It projects the free cash flow a company is expected to produce over ten years, adds a terminal value for every year after that, and discounts it all back to today. If free cash flow is new to you, the post on when earnings and cash disagree covers the input.

Simply Wall St uses four variations depending on the industry and the data available, with a two-stage model as the default and a dividend discount model among the others.

What Sets the Discount Rate

The discount rate is the cost of equity: a risk-free rate plus beta times an equity risk premium. The model document says the risk-free rate is the five-year average of the 10-year government bond rate, chosen because the spot rate makes valuations jump around. Beta is built bottom-up from the industry and is held between 0.8 and 2.

Those are reasonable choices. They are still choices, and the next section shows how much rides on them.

A Worked Example: One Point on the Discount Rate

The valuation guide walks through Microsoft. Ten years of forecast cash flow are worth 858,403 in present value, in the guide's own figures. The terminal value, discounted at 7.17% with 2.15% long-run growth, is worth 1,829,665. Together they make an equity value of 2,688,068.

More than two thirds of that fair value, about 68%, comes from cash flows after year ten. That is normal for a DCF, and it is exactly why the result is sensitive. Here is the same terminal value with the discount rate moved one point either way, our arithmetic on the guide's own year-ten cash flow and growth rate:

Discount ratePresent value of terminal valueChange against the guide
6.17%2,509,580about 37% higher
7.17% (the guide)1,829,665none
8.17%1,390,531about 24% lower

Only the terminal value is recomputed here; the first ten years would shift too, in the same direction. A one point change in an input nobody can observe directly moves the largest piece of fair value by a quarter or more. Pass or fail on "20% below fair value" can flip on that alone.

When Two Fair Values Disagree on One Stock

The community narratives show the same thing from another side. In a 9 November article on Snowflake Inc, a company that happens to share the shape's name, two narratives on the same stock put fair value at US$263 and US$187. The share price at the time was US$276, above both.

Same company, same filings, a US$76 gap between two stories, and a market that agreed with neither. This is a dated example of how valuation models disagree, not a view on that stock.

The site is open about this; the narratives exist so users can put their own assumptions in. The risk is on the reader's side: a fair value printed to the cent looks more certain than the inputs behind it.

Simply Wall St Free vs Premium vs Unlimited

The plans page lists three tiers, and the main difference is how many company reports you can open each month.

FeatureFreePremiumUnlimited
Company or ETF reports5 a month30 a monthUnlimited
Portfolios1, up to 10 holdings3, up to 30 holdings eachUnlimited
Screener resultsTop 4UnlimitedUnlimited
Excel and PDF exportNoNoYes
AdsYesNoNo

Every new account starts with seven days of Premium with no card required, then drops to the Free plan on day eight unless you choose to pay. The plans page we read lists features rather than a price; the price and any sales tax appear at checkout.

What Counts as a Report View

The help center's article on plan limits adds two details that matter on the Free plan. A free user uses a slot the moment a report opens, even by mistake. And each listing counts on its own, so the same company on two exchanges takes two of your five slots.

The limit resets monthly on your subscription date, not on the first of the month. Five reports go fast if you are comparing a handful of companies in one sector.

Is Simply Wall St Reliable? Where It Helps and Where It Misleads

As a way to see a company's fundamentals at a glance, it holds up well. The checks are published, the data comes from a large vendor, and each report section says in plain language what it checked. For a beginner, the Snowflake is a decent map of which questions to ask about a business.

The weak spots follow from the design:

  • Fair value is a model output. It rests on analyst cash flow forecasts, a discount rate and a terminal growth rate, and the worked example above shows how far it can move.
  • Binary checks hide the margin. A near miss and a wide miss both score zero, and the shape does not show which one you are looking at.
  • It reads filings, not the chart. There is nothing about trend, volume or the pattern a stock is drawing right now, which is a separate question from what the business is worth.

None of these make the tool wrong. They mean the Snowflake is where research starts, and the filings and your own assumptions are where it has to finish.

Simply Wall St vs Primo Trade: Different Questions

Primo Trade is our own app, so read this section with that in mind. It answers a different question from Simply Wall St and lacks a lot of what Simply Wall St has.

Simply Wall StPrimo Trade
Main questionWhat is this business worth?What does this stock or chart show?
Way inCompany search, screenerTicker search or a photo of a chart
SummarySnowflake, 30 pass or fail checksPrimo Score, five scores from 0 to 100
Coverage120,000+ stocks, 90+ marketsUS-listed stocks and ADRs
Portfolio and screenerYesNo

The app gives an AI read of a US-listed stock from its ticker, or of a chart from a photo or screenshot: a signal from Strong Buy to Strong Sell as the AI's read, a Primo Score across Risk, Sentiment, Technical, Fundamental and Growth, a strategy idea with a risk level, and key insights. For a ticker it adds recent news and a Forecast Value, the model's 6 to 12 month estimate. A score of 80 is not an 80% chance of anything; it is how the AI weighed what it read.

Primo Trade gives AI-generated analysis for information and education. It is not financial advice. Markets carry risk; do your own research before you trade.

The honest split: if you want a valuation model, global coverage and portfolio tracking, Simply Wall St does that and our app does not. If you want a second read on a chart you are looking at, a chart photo is a way in that Simply Wall St does not offer. Our comparison of AI analysis tools covers what several others read.

Who Simply Wall St Fits, and Who It Does Not

It fits long-term investors who want a structured look at a company's fundamentals without building a spreadsheet, beginners learning which questions to ask about a business, and anyone holding stocks outside the US, since coverage runs to more than 90 markets.

It fits less well if you trade on charts and timing, if you want to set your own valuation inputs line by line, or if you research many companies a month on the Free plan.

The Short Version

The Snowflake is 30 published pass or fail checks across five areas, and its size and colour only count passes. The Value arm leans on a DCF fair value in which more than two thirds of the number comes from years beyond the forecast, so a one point change in the discount rate can move it by a quarter or more. The Free plan gives five reports a month, Premium thirty, Unlimited no cap. Read the Snowflake as a map of where to look, open the checks behind each arm, and treat any fair value as one set of assumptions rather than the price a share should have.